I applied for a position with a business that services schools. I was excited because the educational experiences that the organization offers students is fantastic.
I received an email from the human resources coordinator asking me to call her back because she wanted to review my application with me. I eagerly called back and left a voice mail message.
When we finally got in touch she asked me a couple of questions that I was able to quickly answer and then asked me a direct question. She let me know that because I had not stated my salary expectations in my cover letter that she needed me to let her know over the phone.
I thought to myself that there must be a better way to negotiate salary. I had two paragraphs about the job description and although I had a chance to cruise through their web site I was still ill prepared to answer that question.
I let her know that I didn’t state my desired earnings in the letter because I was unable to research the position at a comparable establishment – there was no other company offering similar services. I said to her that she must know what her budget is and could let me know the salary range that they were offering.
She once again said that she needed me to state my salary requirements. While she laughed, she let me know that for the administrative position, that I could only imagine just how many applicants there were and that some people were saying they would work for $25,000 a year and other applicants wanted up to $50,000 per year. Is it necessary to laugh at someone looking for work during a recession and to be reminded that it’s an employer’s market? I already know that.
I said that I needed to have an interview and get to know more about the role and the company before I could offer her an answer. And then I couldn’t believe what she said next.
She said “I need to know the lowest that you will go.”
Really?
So basically you want to know the minimum that I will work for?
We didn’t talk for much longer after that, I got off the phone as quickly as I could because that left a bad taste in my mouth.
She wanted to know what is the minimum salary I will work for? My husband and I laughed as he phrased what I should have said as a come-back (hindsight is always 20/20 and it’s so much fun to play that game after the fact to get a little laughter back in your life). He said that I should have asked how little work am I expected to do and how easy is the work I’m expected to perform?
I think that it could have been more tactfully handled. Let them hire the $25,000 applicant – I’m assuming she’ll get what she pays for.
Also, I anticipate that if employers are going to use this tactic in their hiring procedures then they are going to perpetuate lower wages for all employees in the future by taking whomever will undercut their competition. And in the end, it comes full circle. When the human resources coordinator loses her job, or chooses to look for a new one she’ll find that she’ll have to state her salary expectations too and likely have to undercut herself as well, even if she was paid more by her last employer. I will not contribute to setting that precedent. I will encourage fair pay for all and fight for it because it is in the best interests for me and my family.
When I was taking self-employment courses we were told over and over again that if we were worth $25 per hour that we were not to sell our services for $10 per hour. If we undercut ourselves then we would undercut all the other people in the industry and then our work would begin to be expected to be offered for only $10 an hour. If established companies intend to attempt to use this trend of paying salaried workers who are willing to undercut themselves to get a job over their competition, then they are going to start problems in the workforce and concerns in regards to fair pay for work. I highly suggest that they think about this before they continue this approach.
And I needed an interview to find out what benefits were being offered (or not), what vacation time I would get, what the dress code was at work, was the outfit large or small, what the hours were like, and how much overtime was required. There were so many things that I needed to know.
I’m finding that this is not a one-time occurrence, and it’s happening to other job hunters as well. What are your thoughts on employers who state in the job listing that they want to know your salary expectations? Do you have any stories to share? C’mon don’t be shy about it. I find that it’s getting tough out there!
